What mine cooling does
The deeper a mine goes, the hotter it gets. The rock is hotter at depth, and the air heats as it goes down the shaft. If nothing is done, the air can become too hot and humid for people to work in. Mine cooling takes heat out of the air before it reaches the workers, so that the wet bulb temperature stays in a range that the body can cope with. It can be done on the surface for the whole mine, underground for a district, or at a single hot heading. For many deep mines, heat is the limit to how deep they can go. Cooling only works together with ventilation: the air carries the cold to the workers and the heat away (see mine ventilation).
The animation is a tall cutaway of a mine. The air is drawn as chevrons, and their colour shows the temperature: amber is warm surface air, cyan is cooled air, and yellow then orange is air that is heating on the way down. Red arrows show heat flowing into the air. Blue pipes carry chilled water, and each main unit that has its own lesson is clickable: the bulk air cooler, the refrigeration plant, the cooling tower, the ice store and the spot cooler.
How it works
- 1Heat gets in. The air heats as it falls down the shaft, because it is compressed by the weight of the air above it: the energy of the fall turns into heat. This is called auto-compression. Dry air gains about 1 °C for every 100 m, so about 12 °C down a 1,200 m shaft, and moist air gains somewhat less. The rock is hotter at depth and gives heat to the air that passes it. Diesel engines, electric motors, blasting, hot water and oxidising ore add more. In the drawing the colour of the cut rock goes from tan to red-brown with depth, and the chevrons change colour as they fall.
- 2Measure it. A thermometer wetted at its bulb gives the wet bulb temperature. It shows how well the body can lose heat by sweating, and it rises with both the temperature and the humidity of the air. About 27 °C wet bulb is a commonly cited point where heat illness becomes much more likely, but this is only a commonly cited figure. Limits and break times differ by state and by site, and each site sets its own in a heat management plan.
- 3Surface bulk air cooler. The simplest and cheapest first step is to cool the intake air on the surface, before it goes down the shaft. The air still heats by about 1 °C for every 100 m on the way down (when it is dry), but it starts its fall colder, so it arrives colder by the amount it was cooled. Surface cooling is also cheaper for each kilowatt, because the plant works at atmospheric conditions and can reject its heat to the open air. The drawing shows the air tunnel at the shaft collar, with sprays and droplet eliminators (see mine air chiller).
- 4Refrigeration plant and chilled water. A refrigeration plant on the surface makes chilled water (see mine refrigeration plant). The water goes to the sprays of the bulk air cooler and down the shaft in a pipe to a cooler underground, with a coil and a fan, so that the air is cooled again nearer the work. The water, now warmer, returns up the shaft to the plant.
- 5Spot cooling. The air is hottest at the end of a dead-end heading, where little air passes. A spot cooler is a small self-contained refrigeration skid that cools the last stretch of air and sends it along a duct to the face. The heat that the skid rejects goes into the air that flows back out of the heading.
- 6Heat rejection. The heat that the plant took from the water, and the heat of the compressors, is carried by condenser water to a cooling tower on the surface and rejected to the atmosphere (see also the condenser lesson). The compressor power adds to the heat that the tower must reject.
- 7Store cold. An ice machine can make ice at night, when electricity is cheapest, and the ice is kept in an insulated dam. By day the ice melts in the water returning from the mine and gives very cold water to the same chilled water main, so that the refrigeration machines can switch off at the peak tariff (see ice thermal storage). Trade material describes one scheme at a deep mine that could switch off about 40 MW of refrigeration this way.
The numbers
The cooling load is the mass flow of the air multiplied by its specific heat and the temperature drop. Typical features, all of them site dependent:
- Auto-compression. Dry air gains about 1 °C for every 100 m it descends. Moist air gains less, because some of the energy goes into evaporating water: typically about half as much in very wet conditions. Cooling on the surface does not remove it; the air gains about the same on the way down.
- Rock temperature. Rock temperature often rises by roughly 1 °C for every 30 to 40 m of depth, but the rate varies a lot from region to region.
- Where to cool. Surface cooling is the simplest. Underground and spot cooling put the cold where it is needed, and cost more to build and to run.
- Skid size. Spot cooler skids are typically of the order of hundreds of kilowatts of cooling.
Worked example. Assume 100 m³/s of air has to be cooled by 8 K, only the dry heat is counted, the air density is 1.2 kg/m³ and its specific heat is 1.005 kJ/(kg K). The refrigeration machines have a coefficient of performance (COP) of 4.
| Quantity | Working | Result |
|---|
| Mass flow of air | 100 × 1.2 | 120 kg/s |
| Cooling load on the air | 120 × 1.005 × 8 | about 965 kW |
| Heating of dry air falling 1,200 m | 1,200 ÷ 100 × 1 °C | about 12 °C |
| Electric power of the refrigeration machines | 965 ÷ 4 | about 240 kW |
| Heat to reject at the cooling tower | 965 + 241 | about 1,200 kW, or 1.2 MW |
The fall of 12 °C is larger than the 8 K that the example cools, which shows why cooling at the surface alone may not be enough for a deep mine. Real loads are larger, because wet air also gives up latent heat when its water condenses on the cold surfaces. The load of the whole mine is the sum of auto-compression, heat from the rock, machinery and other heat; see mine refrigeration plant for the build-up.
Assumed inputs, not data from a particular mine. The example counts only the dry heat of the air and ignores the pumps, the fans and heat gains in the pipes.
Safety: heat limits, break times and the way a mine manages heat differ by state and by mine, and the 27 °C wet bulb figure is only a commonly cited point, not a limit. Heat illness is serious. This lesson explains the idea; it is not a design method, a heat management plan or an operating procedure.
What the operator watches
- Temperatures in the workings. The wet bulb and dry bulb temperatures at the places where people work, especially the hottest headings.
- Chilled water. The supply and return temperatures and the flow. A small difference between them means the load is low or the flow is too high.
- The refrigeration machines. Loading, refrigerant pressures and trips, and the approach of the cooling tower to the outside wet bulb temperature.
- Airflow. Cooling is useless without air to carry it, so the airflow past each cooler and into each heading is watched as closely as the temperature.
Common problems
- Scaling and fouling. Dirty water and dusty air foul coolers and nozzles, and the cooling falls.
- High condensing pressure. A refrigeration machine trips when the tower cannot reject the heat, for example on a hot, humid day.
- Heat lost on the way. Chilled water pipes pick up heat from the warm rock and the air, so the water arrives warmer than it left.
- Sized for the average. Coolers sized for the average load leave the hottest heading short of cold, or short of air.
Words you will meet
- Wet bulb temperature
- A temperature reading that includes the effect of humidity, used to judge heat stress.
- Auto-compression
- The heating of air as it falls down a shaft and is compressed by the air above it.
- Virgin rock temperature
- The temperature of the rock before mining disturbs it. It rises with depth.
- Bulk air cooler
- A plant that cools all the intake air of a mine in one place, usually on the surface.
- Spot cooler
- A small cooling unit that cools the air for one hot heading.
- Chilled water
- Water cooled to a few degrees above freezing and used to carry cold.
- Refrigeration plant
- The machines that make the chilled water; its size is given in kilowatts of refrigeration.
- COP
- Coefficient of performance: the cooling delivered divided by the electric power used.
- Thermal storage
- Keeping cold made at one time, for example as ice, so that it can be used at another.
- Heat management plan
- A site's own plan for limits, breaks and controls in hot conditions.
Check your understanding
Why is surface cooling the first thing to try?
It is the simplest and least expensive place to put the plant, and the air starts its descent colder. The air still gains about 1 °C for every 100 m on the way down (when it is dry), because auto-compression is not removed by surface cooling, so it arrives colder by the amount it was cooled.
Why does cooling need ventilation?
The air carries the cold to the workers and carries the heat away. A cooler with no air passing through it cools nothing that matters.
What does ice storage save?
Peak-tariff electricity. The ice is made when power is cheap and melts when it is dear, so the refrigeration machines can be off at the peak. It usually uses a little more energy in total, but at a lower price.