Silver Recovery: Two Routes (overview)

Silver by flotation into smelter concentrates, or by cyanide leach and zinc precipitation.

Loading the animation…
You are watching a free lesson. A free account saves your progress and lets you mark lessons complete. Create a free account Sign in

What a silver recovery plant does

Silver is often a by-product. It comes out with lead and zinc, with copper or with gold, and in some mines it is the main metal. There are two main ways to get it out of the ore. In the first, the silver minerals are floated with the lead and zinc minerals into concentrates, which are sent to a smelter. In the second, the silver is dissolved from the ground ore with weak cyanide, caught from the solution with zinc dust in a Merrill-Crowe plant, and melted into a doré bar (silver with some gold).

The animation draws both routes on one site, so that they can be compared side by side. They share the crushers and mills at the front. A real plant normally uses the route that suits its ore, and the choice depends on the minerals the silver is in. This lesson gives the principles and typical ranges. It does not describe any particular plant. The gold version of the leach is in the gold processing plant lesson, and the copper version of flotation is in the copper processing plant lesson.

How it works

The ore moves through the plant in one line, then splits into the two routes. Steps 2 and 3 are route 1. Steps 4 to 7 are route 2.

  1. 1Crush and grind. A jaw crusher breaks the ore and a conveyor carries it to the mills. The SAG mill and the ball mill grind it with water to a fine slurry. A hydrocyclone, fed by a slurry pump (see the centrifugal pump), sends the coarse part back to the ball mill and passes the fine part on to one of the two routes.
  2. 2Flotation. The fine slurry goes to a row of flotation cells. In the first cells air and reagents make the lead minerals float as a froth. In many ores the silver minerals go with them. The slurry that sinks is conditioned, and in the next cells the zinc minerals float. What is left sinks and leaves as tailings. The lead-zinc-silver flotation lesson shows these cells in detail.
  3. 3Concentrates to a smelter. Each froth is a concentrate. Each is thickened (see how a thickener works) and filtered on a vacuum disc filter into a damp cake, which is loaded into bags or bins for a smelter. The smelter and refinery are off site and are not drawn. In a lead smelter the silver follows the lead into the bullion, and refining separates it later.
  4. 4Cyanide leach. On the other route, the slurry runs through stirred tanks with weak cyanide solution and air. The silver dissolves into the solution. A vacuum disc filter then separates the pregnant solution from the leached solids. The solids are washed, the cyanide in them is destroyed, and they go to the tailings storage facility together with the flotation tailings.
  5. 5Clarify and deaerate. The pregnant solution first passes through a clarifying filter, so that almost no solids are left in it. It is then drawn into a vacuum tower, where the dissolved oxygen is taken out. Oxygen would waste the zinc in the next step. See Merrill-Crowe zinc precipitation.
  6. 6Zinc precipitation. Zinc dust is fed into the clear, oxygen-free solution. The silver comes out as solid particles, and a filter press collects them as a cake. The barren solution goes back to the leach tanks.
  7. 7Smelt to doré. The precipitate is dried and melted in a furnace with fluxes, then poured into a mould as a doré bar (see electrowinning and smelting, where the same kind of furnace is used for gold). A refinery purifies it later.

The numbers

Silver flowsheets differ a great deal from ore to ore. These are typical ranges and principles, not data from a plant.

ItemTypical value
Grind size for flotationtypically 80 percent of the ore finer than about 75 to 150 micrometres
Water left in a filtered concentrate caketypically about 8 to 12 percent
Dissolved oxygen after the Merrill-Crowe towertypically below about 1 mg/L
Silver melting pointabout 961 °C, so the furnace runs above that

Worked example. Assume the ore holds 150 g of silver in each tonne and the plant treats 100 t/h. Route 1 sends 80 percent of the silver into a lead concentrate that is 3 percent of the feed by mass, 8 percent into a zinc concentrate that is 5 percent of the feed, and the rest to tailings. Route 2 dissolves 90 percent of the silver in the leach and precipitates 99 percent of the dissolved silver.

QuantityWorkingResult
Silver in the feed100 × 150 g15,000 g/h, which is 15.0 kg/h
Route 1: silver in the lead concentrate15.0 × 0.8012.0 kg/h
Mass of lead concentrate100 × 0.033 t/h
Silver grade of the lead concentrate12,000 g ÷ 3 t4,000 g/t, which is about 27 times the feed
Route 1: silver in the zinc concentrate15.0 × 0.081.2 kg/h, in 5 t/h, which is 240 g/t
Route 1: silver left in the tailings15.0 − 12.0 − 1.21.8 kg/h, in 92 t/h, which is about 20 g/t
Route 2: silver dissolved15.0 × 0.9013.5 kg/h
Route 2: silver precipitated13.5 × 0.99about 13.4 kg/h
Route 2: share of the silver recovered0.90 × 0.99about 89 percent

Route 1 does not make silver metal. It makes a small mass of concentrate that is rich in silver, and the smelter and refinery finish the job. Route 2 makes the silver at the mine. The two routes happen to recover about the same share here only because of the assumed figures.

Assumed inputs, not data from a particular plant.

Safety: the leach solution holds cyanide, which is highly toxic and gives off hydrogen cyanide gas if the solution turns acid. Zinc dust can burn when it is dry and dusty. Lead and zinc concentrates are toxic dusts. Smelting handles molten metal. All of them need strict handling rules. This lesson explains the process; it is not a procedure.

What the operator watches

  • Silver in the tailings. On both routes this is the loss, so it is measured often.
  • Froth in the cells. Its depth and colour show whether the minerals are floating well.
  • Cyanide strength and pH in the leach. Too little cyanide slows the leach, and a falling pH is a safety alarm.
  • Oxygen after the tower and the clarity of the solution. They decide how well the zinc works.

Common problems

  • Silver in the wrong mineral. If the silver is locked in a mineral that does not float or does not dissolve well, recovery falls whichever route is used.
  • Cyanide consumers. Other minerals, such as copper and sulphur minerals, use up cyanide and slow the leach.
  • Cloudy solution. Solids that pass the clarifying filter block the press cloths and dirty the precipitate.
  • Air leaks at the tower. Air puts oxygen back into the solution, so the zinc is wasted.

Words you will meet

Concentrate
The small, metal-rich product of flotation.
Rougher cell
A first flotation cell, which takes out the bulk of the wanted mineral.
Smelter
A plant that melts a concentrate to make metal.
Bullion
Impure metal, such as lead with its silver, before refining.
Pregnant solution
Leach solution that carries the dissolved silver.
Barren solution
The same solution after the silver has been taken out.
Merrill-Crowe
Zinc precipitation of silver from a clear, oxygen-free solution.
Doré
A bar of silver with some gold, poured at the mine.

Check your understanding

Why does the lead concentrate often carry most of the silver?

In many ores the silver minerals occur with the lead minerals, so they float with them.

Why is the pregnant solution deaerated before zinc is added?

Oxygen would use up the zinc, so more zinc would be needed and the precipitation would be poorer.

Where does the silver in the concentrate bags go next?

To a smelter and a refinery, which are off site. The smelter melts the concentrate and the silver follows the lead into the bullion, where refining separates it.

Key facts

Route 1
Float the silver with lead and zinc minerals. Concentrates go to a smelter.
Route 2
Leach with cyanide, precipitate with zinc dust, melt to a doré bar.
Shared front end
Crushing, grinding and a hydrocyclone.
Oxygen
Taken to typically below about 1 mg/L before the zinc is added.
Tailings
Both routes send them to one tailings storage facility.
Use the animation
The animation is clickable: click the crusher, the conveyor, a mill, the pump, the cyclone, a flotation cell, a thickener, a vacuum disc filter, the Merrill-Crowe plant or the tailings storage to open its own lesson. Follow the ore from the crusher through the mills to the cyclone. There the slurry splits. Follow one branch to the row of flotation cells and the bags of concentrate. Follow the other through the two leach tanks, the filter, the clarifying filter, the vacuum tower and the filter press to the furnace and the doré bars. The numbers on the drawing match the numbered steps under How it works. Hover over any part for its name and what it does.